Comparing a Manchester Terrier and a Doberman Pinscher
The 7 Main Differences Between a Manchester Terrier and a Doberman Pinscher
Though these two breeds may appear similar, there are notable differences between them. Read on to find out how they compare in breed origin, appearance, size, hair type and color, and temperament.
Manchester Terrier vs Doberman Pinscher: Breed Origin
As their name suggests, Manchester Terriers originated in England. Originally called the black-and-tan terrier, it gained its current name in the 1920s. Breeders in Manchester and elsewhere crossed whippets (racing dogs) with black-and-tan terriers (ratters) to create the Manchester Terrier. Their raison d’être was vermin hunting, especially killing rats in factories, but they were also capable of hunting other small game like rabbits. Today, they are mainly companion pets. Doberman Pinschers originated in the town of Apolda in the German state of Thuringia. Louis Dobermann, a dogcatcher and dog pound owner, created the breed in 1890 by crossing several other breeds. These include the Rottweiler, German Pinscher, Black and Tan Terrier, Weimaraner, and short-haired shepherd. The American Kennel Club first officially recognized the breed in 1908. Dobermann bred these dogs as guard dogs; since then, they have served as police, military, and private guard dogs around the world.
Manchester Terrier vs Doberman Pinscher: Appearance
The Manchester Terrier is an elegant, athletic dog with a sleek physique to match its racing and ratting origins. The head is narrow and wedge-shaped with a long, tapered muzzle. The ears can be either erect (V-shaped) or button ears (folded). Erect ears are more common among toy Manchester Terriers than standard. The body is lean but sturdy with muscular legs, and the tail is long and tapered. Doberman Pinschers appear similar in head and body shape to Manchester Terriers, though they are significantly larger. Called the “noblemen” of dogs, Dobermans are lean but muscular in body with long, athletic legs. Breeders often crop their ears to make them stand erect; Doberman ears are naturally floppy. Their tails, when not docked, are long and curved.
Manchester Terrier vs Doberman Pinscher: Size
Manchester Terriers come in two sizes: standard and toy. Though these used to be considered separate breeds, breeders today recognize them as different types within the same breed. Standard Manchester Terriers stand 15-16 inches at the shoulder and weigh between 12-22 pounds. Toy Manchester Terriers are somewhat smaller, with a height of 10-12 inches and a weight not exceeding 12 pounds. Males and females have little difference between them. Doberman Pinschers are much larger dogs. Males stand 27-28 inches at the shoulder, averaging 70 pounds. Females stand 25-27 inches at the shoulder with an average weight of 60-65 pounds.
Manchester Terrier vs Doberman Pinscher: Hair Type and Colour
Dog fanciers adore the Manchester Terrier for its sleek, glossy coat. The hair is short but not soft, lying close to the body. This breed sheds, though not abundantly; shedding may increase in spring and fall. There is only one possible color for Manchester Terriers: black with tan markings on the head, chest, and legs. Doberman Pinschers are also famous for their sleek, glossy coats, often groomed to a high shine. The hair is extremely short and close to the body. Dobermans are moderate shedders; regular brushing will help reduce this. They come in a wider range of colors than Manchester Terriers, including black, blue, red, and fawn. Rust-colored markings appear on the face, body, and tail.
Manchester Terrier vs Doberman Pinscher: Temperament
Manchester Terriers make good pets for experienced dog owners who know how to be firm and consistent in their training. Inexperienced dog owners may find this breed’s natural independence and occasional stubbornness frustrating. However, its keen intelligence and loyal nature pay rich dividends to anyone who can master it. These terriers love their owners and make excellent watchdogs with an alert temperament and discerning nature. They are well-mannered but high-energy, requiring frequent walks and romps and abundant mental stimulation. Like the Manchester Terrier, the Doberman Pinscher is highly intelligent and quick to learn. This breed tends toward ready obedience to a firm and trusted trainer. They are alert, loyal pets with lots of energy. They are gentle and loving with the right handling, but they are also extremely fearless and can be aggressive if not trained properly. Given this dog’s size and history as a guard dog, owners must take extra care to ensure it is properly socialized and conditioned.
Manchester Terrier vs Doberman Pinscher: Life Expectancy
Manchester Terriers are long-lived dogs with a typical lifespan of 15-17 years. Though they are generally healthy, they may suffer from various ailments. The most common of these is juvenile cardiomyopathy, a disease-causing sudden cardiac arrest in dogs between 10-52 weeks old. Other possible issues include von Willebrand Disease (a bleeding disorder), autoimmune hypothyroidism (issues with the immune system and metabolism), and glaucoma (an eye disease). Unlike Manchester Terriers, Doberman Pinschers only live between 10-13 years. This is not surprising, given their status as large dogs. Dilated cardiomyopathy (a condition leading to heart failure) is one of this breed’s most common health issues. Individuals may also suffer from von Willebrand Disease, chronic active hepatitis (a liver disorder), or cervical vertebral instability (a spinal disease causing difficulty walking).
Manchester Terrier vs Doberman Pinscher: Grooming Needs
Manchester Terriers are generally clean dogs without any odor. Owners should brush their dog weekly with a curry comb or mitt to keep its coat clean and reduce shedding. Because Manchesters’ coats are so short, tangling and matting shouldn’t be a problem. A bath every 3 months is sufficient, though they should be bathed if they get dirty. Use a conditioner or polish formulated for dogs for an especially glossy coat. Doberman Pinschers also need little grooming due to their short hair, and weekly brushing and a bath every couple of months should do it. As with Manchester Terriers, a curry comb or mitt will remove dirt and loose hair without irritating the skin. Though both breeds can be a handful, they make loyal, intelligent pets in the hands of an experienced dog owner.
